Students explore how radius changes surface area with fixed cylinder volume, graph the relationship and write an area function. Positive dimensions constrain the physical domain. HSA.CED.A.4/HSF.IF.B.5: eliminate height through fixed volume and interpret rational relationship; provided table/tool scaffolds formulation.
Fixing a cylinder’s volume makes height depend on radius, which then determines surface area. Students combine formulas to express one varying quantity in terms of another and interpret the resulting rational function.
Practice #1 evaluates cylinder height at several radii using a supplied fixed-volume relation. The procedure must preserve the squared-radius denominator and the units of height.
Students express cylinder surface area while holding volume fixed. Substituting the constraint creates a rational function whose positive radius domain is essential when comparing designs.
The earlier box problem maximizes volume under a construction constraint; the cylinder problem fixes volume and compares surface area. Solving the constraint introduces a rational expression with a meaningful positive domain.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4; 2.1 task · PDF p. 2, Activity 1.3
The main task asks how radius affects area and requires an equation after numerical and graphical exploration. The can-design extension challenges the assumption that minimum material is the only manufacturing concern.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4; TE Student task, anticipated reasoning and Activity Synthesis
Teacher guidance uses poured liquids or a physical can to connect symbols with volume and surface area. It also addresses exponent-grouping errors and helps students eliminate height using the volume relation.
TE 16.2 Launch and Anticipated Misconceptions; 16.3; SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
MP2 is supported by coordinating radius, height, fixed volume and surface-area units. An algebraic value for a nonpositive physical dimension does not describe a usable can.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4; TE Activity monitoring, Anticipated Misconceptions, Activity Synthesis and Lesson Synthesis
The teacher compares computed heights and the shape of students’ graphs before the surface-area model is assembled. This can expose a formula or exponent error before it distorts the optimization conclusion.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4; TE Activity monitoring, Anticipated Misconceptions, Activity Synthesis and Lesson Synthesis
Summative assessment: Protected assessment items and scoring guidance were not reviewed.
Coherence: vertical alignment: An explicit prior-grade connection was not verified for this lesson.
Additional source references
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
Relate radius/height/surface area with fixed452 cubic centimeters; construct equation for area as function of radius. Table and graphing tool are supplied.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 4, Are you ready for more? #1–2
Compare real can dimensions with minimum-area cylinder and consider manufacturing constraints beyond minimum material.
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
Relate radius/height/surface area with fixed452 cubic centimeters; construct equation for area as function of radius. Table and graphing tool are supplied.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 4, Are you ready for more? #1–2
Compare real can dimensions with minimum-area cylinder and consider manufacturing constraints beyond minimum material.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
Relate radius/height/surface area with fixed452 cubic centimeters; construct equation for area as function of radius. Table and graphing tool are supplied.
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
Relate radius/height/surface area with fixed452 cubic centimeters; construct equation for area as function of radius. Table and graphing tool are supplied.
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 4, Are you ready for more? #1–2
Compare real can dimensions with minimum-area cylinder and consider manufacturing constraints beyond minimum material.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 4, Are you ready for more? #1–2
Compare real can dimensions with minimum-area cylinder and consider manufacturing constraints beyond minimum material.
TE 16.2 Launch/Misconceptions;16.3 Launch/Synthesis
Use poured liquids/can perimeter models; distinguish exponent grouping; help substitute height out of area formula. Interpret fixed volume and build rational surface-area function. Physical representations support meaning of quantities and formula rearrangement.
SE 2.16 task · PDF p. 3, Activity16.3 #1–4
Students explore how radius changes surface area with fixed cylinder volume, graph the relationship and write an area function. Positive dimensions constrain the physical domain.
SE 2.16 practice · PDF p. 1, Practice #1, #2, #3 including subparts/continuations