SE 2.22 practice · PDF p. 2, Practice#2,#3
Locate algebraic error that led Kiran to false no-solutions claim, then calculate correct solutions; failed substitution alone does not diagnose cause.
Gateway 2 · ML-R07
Students construct justified mathematical arguments and critique others’ reasoning in connection with course content.
See related lesson evidence in the PDF
Argument and critique are recurring mathematical work, not just directions to explain. Students compare valid index interpretations, reject insufficient graph/factor evidence, diagnose lost/extraneous solutions and prove identities.
Not all practice requires justification; protected sample responses limit verification of the full range of modeled arguments.
Ask which claim/condition justifies each conclusion; preserve false examples as objects of critique, not curriculum errors.
SE 2.22 practice · PDF p. 2, Practice#2,#3
Locate algebraic error that led Kiran to false no-solutions claim, then calculate correct solutions; failed substitution alone does not diagnose cause.
TE 8.3 Activity, Anticipated Misconceptions and Synthesis
Explain both index conventions valid; encourage tables starting at each defined first index and clarify assumptions. Compare recurrence and two explicit forms without assuming one must be wrong. Directly resolves prior report inference; precision rests on meaning of index.
TE 5.2 Launch/Misconceptions;5.3 Launch/Misconceptions/Synthesis
Allow selected practice items; use substitution to test sign errors; assign explanation/listening roles and require checking enough graph features. Find zeros, justify matches and check similar graphs. Differentiation preserves zero/factor reasoning and critiques overly weak matching evidence.
TE 11.2 Launch, Anticipated Misconceptions and Synthesis
Discourage cancelling a shared factor without considering zero; select differing solution approaches and compare to intersection graphs. Explain all intersections and preserve lost-solution cases. Error cause and alternative methods support reasoning and instructional response.
TE 22.2 Launch/Synthesis;22.3 Launch/Misconceptions;Lesson Synthesis
Use peer explanation/revision for extraneous roots; compare different difficulty rankings and remind quadratic methods if needed. Justify exclusions, choose tasks, solve algebraically and reflect on non-equivalence. Strategic choice and metacognitive explanation are explicit; graphing not appropriate substitute for intended algebra.
TE 24.1 Synthesis;24.2 Launch/Misconceptions/Synthesis;24.4 Launch
Record failing constructions, clarify hypotenuse and side restrictions, select alternative proofs, use feedback prompts and sentence frames. Prove identity, distinguish geometric constraints and revise written explanation. Intentional failure, argumentation, language and contingent response work together.
SE 1.6 task · PDF p. 2, Activity6.2, matching directions
Each partner must explain a recurrence/sequence match and evaluate the other explanation; unmatched entries require creating a representation.
SE 1.8 task · PDF p. 3, Activity8.3 #1–2
Sierpinski picture leaves starting-step interpretation open. Both explicit formulas generate1,3,9,27 under their respective domains: Andre indexes from0 and Lin from1. Original TE1.8 Activity8.3 explicitly confirms both valid. Compare equivalent sequence representations and assumptions, not declare either student wrong.
SE 2.23 task · PDF p. 1, Activity23.2 #1–2
Evaluate claims about differences of squares of consecutive integers/even integers; counterexample challenges overgeneralization, symbolic expressions support proof.
SE 2.24 task · PDF p. 2, Activity24.2 #1–2
TE 8.3 Activity, Anticipated Misconceptions and Activity Synthesis
Both Sierpinski explicit rules valid with different initial-index conventions; encourage tables and clear meaning of n. Provides counterevidence to treating one as wrong.
SE 2.22 task · PDF p. 1, Activity22.2 #1–2
Evaluate Jada calculation and explain why multiplying produces root where original denominator vanishes.
SE 1.1 task · PDF p. 2, Activity1.2 #1–5
Students solve Tower of Hanoi cases, explain how a smaller solution informs a larger case, and predict larger minimum counts. The rules constrain allowable moves; a trial alone does not prove minimality.
SE 1.3 task · PDF p. 2, Activity3.3, Jada/Mai claim and table
Students judge whether tripling between displayed table rows establishes a geometric sequence. The last displayed term index skips three positions, so adjacent displayed values are not consecutive terms.
SE 1.6 task · PDF p. 2, Activity6.2 matching directions, sequences and definitions
Partners explain recurrence/sequence matches, listen to and evaluate explanations, and create missing matches. Matching requires initial value as well as additive/multiplicative rule.
SE 1.7 task · PDF p. 2, Activity7.2 Info Gap directions
Students request specific information, explain why it is needed, solve independently after gathering it and discuss reasoning.
SE 1.9 task · PDF p. 1, Activity9.2 #1–3
Students tabulate remaining cake, write both recursive and nonrecursive definitions and explain a reasonable domain. Form selection and domain interpretation are required, beyond calculating successive fractions.
SE 2.4 task · PDF p. 2, Activity4.2 #7–9; Activity4.3 #1–2 and response directions
Students transfer closure questions from integers to polynomial addition/subtraction/multiplication, test examples and explain generally using chosen representations.
SE 2.5 task · PDF p. 3, Activity5.3 partner explanation directions; equation list on PDFp2
Students match factored polynomials to graphs/descriptions and justify each match while responding to disagreement. Zeros require the opposite sign of the linear-factor constant.
SE 2.7 task · PDF p. 2, Activity7.2 #1–3; claim and graph on PDFp1
Students refute a polynomial-degree claim based on a misleading graph window, justify a better window and choose one for a new polynomial.
SE 2.8 task · PDF p. 3, Activity8.3 #1–3; Lesson8 Summary
Students identify degree, compare term values at specified inputs and explain polynomial end behavior. Eventually dominant leading behavior must be distinguished from values near zero.
SE 2.9 task · PDF p. 1, Activity9.2 #1–2
Students construct even- and odd-degree polynomials satisfying stated end behaviors and explain their reasoning. Degree parity and leading sign both constrain valid answers.
SE 2.15 task · PDF p. 3, Activity15.3 #1a–f,#2a–b,#3
Students identify possible factors, justify a nonfactor, divide to find its remainder and compare all remainders with function evaluation. Summary on PDFp4 supplies general converse/theorem proof.
SE 2.18 task · PDF p. 2, Activity18.2 #1–4
Students interpret average book-printing cost, estimate profit threshold, question half-book input and explain end behavior in context.
SE 2.20 task · PDF p. 2, Activity20.3 #1–3
Students write and solve a batting-average equation, then revise it after three further at-bats without a hit and explain each step. Both numerator and denominator change when subsequent hits are added.
SE 2.23 task · PDF p. 1, Activity23.2 #1–2
Students prove or refute claims about differences of consecutive integer squares. The even-integer claim is deliberately overstated and requires counterexample or corrected general reasoning.
SE 2.24 task · PDF p. 2, Activity24.2 #1–2; warm-up instructions PDFp1
Students express triangle sides using two integers and prove the identity underlying the construction. Original teacher synthesis intentionally asks for failing choices and separates identity truth from geometric restrictions.