Review summary

Gateway 2 · ML-R07

Argument and critique — MP3

Students construct justified mathematical arguments and critique others’ reasoning in connection with course content.

2 / 3 · provisional

See related lesson evidence in the PDF

What the evidence supports

Students evaluate Zac and Sione’s strategies and justify equivalence; TE 2.3 asks groups to defend disagreements with representations.

Limits and counterevidence

Direct critique of another person’s reasoning is concentrated in 2.5.

What remains to be checked

Extend independent critique opportunities across the module.

Source evidence

SE PDF p. 30 (printed p. 28), #1

Evaluate both strategies and support with representations.

SE PDF p. 31 (printed p. 29), #2–5

Evaluate equivalent line rules, notice pattern and generalize to point (a,b), slope m.

SE PDF p. 33 (printed p. 31), #10–11

Explain why constant-slope pattern works and whether it applies to any linear function.

TE PDF p. 29, Explore; Discuss

Ask what missing information is needed; use representations to justify disagreement.