Review summary

Gateway 2 · ML-R09

Strategic tools — MP5

Students consider tool usefulness and make strategic choices. Following prescribed tool directions alone is insufficient.

1 / 3 · provisional

Read the PDF summary

What the evidence supports

Original 2.26 teacher guidance explicitly makes technology available without requiring it, creating a tool-choice opportunity. Across the reviewed materials, many tasks prescribe graphing/spreadsheet use and provide limited prompts for students to explain a tool’s usefulness. Some support is present, with substantial gaps for this precise strategic-choice criterion.

Limits and counterevidence

No independent-tool-selection credit is assigned for choosing equation form or graph window; availability is an affordance, not observed student choice.

What remains to be checked

Where MP 5 is a goal, ask students to explain why a tool is useful and what its limitations are; retain prescribed-tool instruction when learning the tool is the goal.

Source evidence

TE Preparation Narrative;26.1 Warm-up;26.3 Launch/Misconceptions/Synthesis

Make technology available but not required; clarify deposit timing; suggest five-year expansion if students cannot begin; return to prediction. Choose approach, apply sum and summarize use. Scaffolding decreases after derivation while preserving quantity/timing demands.

TE Preparation Required Materials/Preparation;4.3 Launch and Synthesis

Teach spreadsheet cells/fill-down and graphing table changes; demonstrate if needed; compare graph that is not a function. Manipulate values/formulas and explain graphical effect with partner. Technology serves functional structure; prescribed tool is not independent tool choice.

TE Preparation Lesson Narrative;10.2 Synthesis;10.3 Anticipated Misconceptions

Describe tasks as relatively unscaffolded; compare representations and prompt prior strategies if students cannot start. Choose a useful representation/form and explain population/square patterns. Explicit progression toward independence while retaining contingent support.

TE 7.2 Synthesis;7.3 Launch/Misconceptions

Ask which factor structure informed viewing window; check early progress; have students test factor-sign mistakes with graphing. Explain settings, create possible functions and compare alternatives. Genuine setting choice/usefulness, still not proof of choosing among tools.

SE 2.7 task · PDF p. 1, Activity7.2, Mai claim

SE 2.7 task · PDF p. 2, Activity7.2 #1–3 and7.3 #1–5

Students explain and choose viewing-window settings, then construct polynomials from intercepts and check graphs. Tool setting choice is evident, independent tool selection is not proved.

TE Lesson Narrative; Required Materials; Required Preparation

Optional technology lesson develops spreadsheet cell/formula/fill-down and plotting skills; teacher preparation identifies graphing/spreadsheet devices and recommended tools.

TE Lesson Narrative; Learning Goals

Builds on sum derivation, reconnects investments, requests prediction return; technology available for student choice but not required.

SE 1.9 practice · PDF p. 3, Practice#6a–b,#7

Explain recursive/explicit equivalence, choose a form to calculate a distant term, justify choice; arithmetic500th term makes efficiency relevant.