Review summary

Gateway 2 · ML-R05

Problem solving — MP1

Tasks develop problem sense-making, perseverance and reflection on solution paths in connection with course content.

2 / 3 · provisional

See related lesson evidence in the PDF

What the evidence supports

Teacher moves support sense-making, persistence and reconsideration of unsuccessful approaches. Avoiding early demonstration, contingent hints, comparing plans and analyzing extraneous solutions preserve meaningful student decisions.

Limits and counterevidence

Many procedures/tools remain prescribed; written opportunity is not evidence of enacted perseverance.

What remains to be checked

Use prompts about progress and unsuccessful approaches before providing the method; preserve time for comparison.

Source evidence

SE 2.22 task · PDF p. 2, Activity22.3 #1a–i,#2

Screen nine equations for impossible inputs; identify easiest/hardest before solving and justify. Next page chooses equations from both lists.

TE 1.1 Launch

Avoid demonstrating a sample sequence first; ask partners to compare different correct lists. Choose initial value, generate sequence and verify partner calculations. Preserves students making mathematical objects rather than copying a model.

TE 1.2 Anticipated Misconceptions;1.3 Launch/Misconceptions/Synthesis

Check ruler reading and double cutout subtraction; have groups compare optimization plans and revisit unsimplified volumes. Construct model, justify dimensions and interpret physical domain. Support responds to causes of measurement/modeling errors without giving general formula first.

TE 7.2 Synthesis;7.3 Launch/Misconceptions

Ask which factor structure informed viewing window; check early progress; have students test factor-sign mistakes with graphing. Explain settings, create possible functions and compare alternatives. Genuine setting choice/usefulness, still not proof of choosing among tools.

TE 22.2 Launch/Synthesis;22.3 Launch/Misconceptions;Lesson Synthesis

Use peer explanation/revision for extraneous roots; compare different difficulty rankings and remind quadratic methods if needed. Justify exclusions, choose tasks, solve algebraically and reflect on non-equivalence. Strategic choice and metacognitive explanation are explicit; graphing not appropriate substitute for intended algebra.

SE 2.1 task · PDF p. 2, Activities1.2 #1–2 and1.3 #1–2

Construct a box, compute volume with cubic-inch units, make a plan to maximize volume, pause for teacher plan review, then write volume expression. Graphing step follows on p3.

SE 2.24 task · PDF p. 1, Activity24.1 directions

Students explicitly test whether integer instructions always yield a right triangle. Failure cases are intentional objects of inquiry.

TE 24.1 Activity Synthesis;24.2 Launch, Anticipated Misconceptions and Synthesis;24.4 Launch

Teacher intentionally elicits failing triangles; selects contrasting proof methods; explains hypotenuse confusion; MLR1 peer feedback/revision and MLR8 sentence frames support written reasoning.

SE 2.22 practice · PDF p. 2, Practice#2,#3

Locate algebraic error that led Kiran to false no-solutions claim, then calculate correct solutions; failed substitution alone does not diagnose cause.