Use the same 58 criteria to examine the materials in front of you. Each indicator includes its full definition and the evidence to check before making a judgment.
Record the evidence before rating.Identify the edition, source page and question number. Explain how the material supports the criterion, including any limits or counterevidence.
GATEWAY 1
Standards and progression
10 indicators
ML-F01
Content demands
Materials address every required action, mathematical object, representation and constraint in the target standards. Teacher demonstrations and student opportunities are identified separately.
Evidence to check
Map each required action, object, representation and constraint to actual content; distinguish teacher demonstrations from student work.
ML-F02
Student independence
Students receive sustained opportunities to learn and independently demonstrate the mathematics, with supports reduced appropriately.
Evidence to check
Locate student tasks and independent practice for each required demand; a teacher solution alone is insufficient.
ML-F03
Content priority
Most instructional time serves the framework’s course priorities. Supporting and prerequisite topics strengthen that work rather than displace it.
Evidence to check
Use intended pacing and a documented time denominator; for CCSS high-school benchmarking identify widely applicable prerequisites, not K–8 major-work labels.
ML-F04
Course-level complexity
Number systems, function families, contexts and reasoning match the demands of Algebra 1 and the adopted framework.
Evidence to check
Check actual contexts, number types and mathematical complexity against the adopted course expectations.
ML-F05
Within-course connections
Tasks connect related ideas within the course and, where required, across the series. Students use the connection to explain, solve or extend mathematics; repetition alone is insufficient.
Evidence to check
Cite connected tasks and explain the mathematical relationship students use; repeated topic labels alone are insufficient.
ML-F06
Prior and later learning
Materials explicitly build on relevant earlier-grade knowledge and show how it supports current and later mathematics. A prerequisite list alone is insufficient.
Evidence to check
Locate explicit earlier-grade knowledge and its use in current work; verify subsequent connections where claimed.
ML-F07
Optional advanced content
Optional advanced work is identified and supports the course without displacing expectations for all students.
Evidence to check
Identify required versus optional advanced work and whether it displaces core learning.
ML-F08
Mathematical modeling
Required modeling tasks involve formulating situations, choosing mathematics, interpreting results and evaluating or revising the model.
Evidence to check
Trace the required modeling cycle across tasks; identify student decisions, interpretation, validation and revision where demanded.
ML-F09
Correlation accuracy
A year-long sequence accurately connects standards and their component demands to lessons, tasks and assessments.
Evidence to check
Check the year-long sequence and correlations against actual tasks; a partial sample cannot establish complete course coverage.
ML-F10
Assessment coverage
Assessments elicit the full mathematical demands of the standards and practices they claim to assess.
Evidence to check
Inspect actual assessments across the declared scope for full standard and practice demands; a correlation table alone is insufficient.
GATEWAY 2
Rigor and mathematical practice
12 indicators
ML-R01
Conceptual understanding
Tasks intentionally develop conceptual understanding through student explanations, representations and mathematical connections where the standards require it.
Evidence to check
Locate student explanations and representations that reveal mathematical meaning; pictures or worked examples alone are insufficient.
ML-R02
Procedural development
Purposeful practice, strategies and feedback develop procedural accuracy, flexibility and efficiency where the standards require them.
Evidence to check
Trace purposeful practice, strategies and feedback over time; exercise count alone does not establish fluency.
ML-R03
Application
Students use mathematics in meaningful applications and interpret results where the standards require it.
Evidence to check
Identify contextual tasks requiring students to use mathematics and interpret the result; decorative contexts do not establish application.
ML-R04
Rigor balance
Conceptual, procedural and application work reflect the standards’ demands, both separately and together. Balance does not mean equal thirds.
Evidence to check
Read the standards first and compare the intended distribution of conceptual, procedural and application work; do not require equal thirds.
ML-R05
Problem solving — MP1
Tasks develop problem sense-making, perseverance and reflection on solution paths in connection with course content.
Evidence to check
Locate problem sense-making, sustained solution attempts and opportunities to monitor or revise approaches.
ML-R06
Quantitative reasoning — MP2
Tasks develop reasoning between quantities, units and symbolic representations, including interpretation of results.
Evidence to check
Show how students move between quantities, units and abstract representations and interpret their results.
ML-R07
Argument and critique — MP3
Students construct justified mathematical arguments and critique others’ reasoning in connection with course content.
Evidence to check
Locate both construction of arguments and critique of reasoning; explanation alone does not establish both.
ML-R08
Modeling practice — MP4
Students construct mathematical models, interpret results and examine their reasonableness in context.
Evidence to check
Locate student model construction and interpretation or checking in context; an assigned representation alone is insufficient.
ML-R09
Strategic tools — MP5
Students consider tool usefulness and make strategic choices. Following prescribed tool directions alone is insufficient.
Evidence to check
Locate strategic student tool selection or evaluation of usefulness; following a prescribed graphing direction alone is insufficient.
ML-R10
Precision — MP6
Tasks develop precision in mathematical meaning, notation, units, calculation and communication.
Evidence to check
Locate demands for precise meaning, units, notation and communication within substantive mathematics.
ML-R11
Structure — MP7
Students recognize and use mathematical structure to explain relationships and solve problems.
Evidence to check
Identify the structure students recognize and how they use it to reason or solve.
ML-R12
Repeated reasoning — MP8
Students use repeated reasoning to form and examine generalizations. Repetitive practice alone is insufficient.
Evidence to check
Identify repeated reasoning, the generalization it supports, and how students examine its validity; repetitive exercises alone are insufficient.
GATEWAY 3
Teaching and participation
21 indicators
ML-T01
Learning and practice
Learning tasks and practice exercises have clear mathematical purposes and appropriate expectations for student thinking.
Evidence to check
Distinguish learning tasks from practice and identify the mathematical purpose and thinking required.
ML-T02
Task sequence
Tasks build understanding and independence through purposeful sequencing, transitions and appropriate increases in demand.
Evidence to check
Trace the sequence, transitions and changes in demand through actual lessons, including opportunities for independent work.
ML-T03
Response variety
Materials vary learning approaches and ways students demonstrate understanding across lessons.
Evidence to check
Show varied approaches and response forms across time, not merely several formats in one task.
ML-T04
Representations and models
Physical and virtual models accurately represent the mathematics and connect to written methods where appropriate.
Evidence to check
Inspect actual manipulatives and diagrams for mathematical accuracy and connections to written methods where appropriate.
ML-T05
Readable design
Visual organization supports reading, navigation and mathematical engagement without unnecessary distraction.
Evidence to check
Inspect representative print and digital pages for legibility, navigation and distraction; source text alone cannot establish visual quality.
ML-T06
Planning and pacing
Teachers can identify learning goals, time requirements, lesson relationships and practical preparation needs.
Evidence to check
Check goals, lesson relationships, intended time and preparation guidance against the supplied teaching materials.
ML-T07
Teaching guidance
Actionable teacher guidance supports launches, questions, monitoring, discussion and synthesis, including use of ancillary materials.
Evidence to check
Locate actionable teacher annotations for launch, questions, monitoring, discussion and synthesis, including use of ancillary materials.
ML-T08
Teacher mathematics
Accurate explanations, examples and alternative approaches strengthen teachers’ mathematical understanding and knowledge of progression.
Evidence to check
Check explanations and worked examples for accuracy, alternative approaches and support for teacher mathematical understanding.
ML-T09
Standards context
Teacher guidance explains how lessons contribute to the standards and where further learning is required.
Evidence to check
Locate explanations of the standards’ role and progression, not just printed codes.
ML-T10
Family communication
Students and caregivers receive understandable program information and practical ways to support progress.
Evidence to check
Inspect actual student and caregiver communication, accessibility and practical guidance for supporting progress.
ML-T11
Instructional rationale
Materials explain instructional approaches, their standards connections and the research supporting specific claims.
Evidence to check
Locate explanations of instructional approaches and trace cited research to the claims it supports; do not infer effectiveness from a citation.
ML-T12
Materials and supplies
Required physical and digital supplies are clearly identified for instructional planning.
Evidence to check
Check that a usable supplies list covers required physical, digital and ancillary materials.
ML-S01
Scaffolds and fading
Scaffolds support access to demanding mathematics and are reduced as students gain independence.
Evidence to check
Locate scaffolds tied to specific barriers and guidance for maintaining demand and increasing independence.
ML-S02
Learner differences
Actionable supports address identified learner needs while maintaining regular participation in course-level mathematics.
Evidence to check
Locate actionable support for identified learner needs and regular participation in course-level mathematics.
ML-S03
Multiple entry points
Tasks provide meaningful entry points and extensions without lowering the intended mathematical demand.
Evidence to check
Inspect entry points and extensions in actual tasks; confirm they preserve the intended mathematical goal.
ML-S04
Multilingual participation
Language goals, discourse supports and teacher guidance develop multilingual learners’ participation in mathematics over time.
Evidence to check
Trace language-development routines, discourse supports and teacher guidance across lessons; generic vocabulary lists alone are insufficient.
ML-S05
Advanced learning
Recurring extensions deepen course mathematics for advanced learners rather than simply add routine work.
Evidence to check
Locate recurring opportunities to deepen course mathematics; additional routine work alone is insufficient.
ML-S06
Representation of people
People are represented respectfully, with meaningful opportunities for students to connect with the materials.
Evidence to check
Inspect representation across materials for respectful variety and meaningful participation, rather than inferring inclusion from one image.
ML-S07
Collaborative grouping
Grouping strategies serve mathematical purposes and support active student participation.
Evidence to check
Locate varied grouping purposes, teacher guidance and ways for students to contribute mathematically.
ML-S08
Language and community
Teacher guidance draws on students’ languages, cultural experiences and community knowledge to enrich mathematical learning.
Evidence to check
Locate explicit guidance for using students’ languages, cultural experiences and community knowledge in mathematical learning.
ML-S09
Reading access
Reading supports improve access without removing the mathematical reasoning or changing the learning goal.
Evidence to check
Locate reading supports for varied needs and verify that they preserve mathematical reasoning.
GATEWAY 4
Assessment and implementation
15 indicators
ML-A01
Prior knowledge
Diagnostic tasks reveal the prerequisite knowledge and understanding needed for upcoming learning.
Evidence to check
Inspect diagnostic prompts and guidance linking prerequisite results to upcoming instruction.